You offer three explanations for Green MPs and councillors opposing the motion: ignorance, racism, or pressure. There is a fourth, and it was on the table months before conference.
Plenty of us fed in similar concerns early on. I, for example, suggested swapping contested definitions for documented state crimes. Committing equally to fighting anti-Jewish and anti-Palestinian racism. Turning transparency calls into actual divestment from occupation-linked companies. Grounding solutions in self-determination, not imposition. When I fed back, all of these were deficient in the draft, and there seemed to be little change in the final version.
The proposed amendments to fix these issues were voted down. So, despite my public position on all this, had I been at conference I would have voted against it too.
Motions are legislative instruments, not campaigning slogans. This motion, as drafted, was a straitjacket: it left little room to hold the government of Israel to account while recognising the deep attachment many people feel, including Jewish constituents who wrote to me worried about what it signalled.
Opposing the motion's drafting is not opposing Palestinians. It's protecting the policy from being dismissed on a technicality, which is precisely what opponents of accountability want.
Politicians need space to do that work.
The motion has generated hundreds of messages to my inbox, all read. However, from constituents in my actual ward of Wotton, North Nibley and Stinchcombe in rural Gloucestershire I've received none. National shouting matches are loud; the people I answer to have stayed quiet.
If you want to shape Green Party policy, join us. This is where change happens.
