Join Nostr
2025-12-15 13:50:50 UTC
in reply to

MarjorieR on Nostr: as a (retired) Operational Researcher while I agree with the inapplicability of JIT ...

as a (retired) Operational Researcher while I agree with the inapplicability of JIT to hospital bed and staff provision, JIT was intended as a way of managing production process without having to hold large buffer stocks of inventory between processes.
However what is relies on is not that demand is entirely constant but that the demand changes can to predicted and that material can be supplied at relatively short notice and processes speeded up when needed.
In the case of hospitals although there is a roughly predictable variation between summer and winter it is not entirely so - witness the latest flu surge - or the effect of snow increasing the number of falls. And the workforce can't be varied much in the same way to follow load.
In practice what hospitals do is postpone scheduled 'elective', non-emergency admissions (such as hip and knee replacements) to try and create capacity for emergency ones. They also end up having to put patients from the in-demand speciality into other wards. This simply increases problems elsewhere and increases overall waiting times for treatment.
I doubt if anyone in the NHS actually thinks it is operating a JIT system. It's entirely inappropriate. At a strategic level they are just not managing it well and not putting what money they do have into tackling the biggest bottlenecks in the most cost-effective way.